Following consultation with our members, CaSE responded to Lord Stern’s review of the Research Excellence Framework.
CaSE submission to Stern Review of REF 2016
18 Mar 2016
Summary of key points
- Introducing further major change at a time of multiple reforms to the research funding and regulatory environment and to university teaching could be destabilising
- In the short-term, maintain the current structure but build in lessons learnt from the 2014 exercise
- There will be efficiency gains from the sector understanding the REF process and having institutional processes in place to respond
- Peer review provides a robust, transparent and credible basis for assessing outputs and should continue to be the basis of assessment, with metrics providing supplementary input
- Changing staff and output selection by decoupling of individuals from outputs, is the most substantial change proposed that could bring significant benefits and efficiencies
- Introducing small changes that would enable better use of the data from the REF could maximise the benefits of the exercise
- Further technical consultation will enable those with experience of REF2014 to help refine the next REF exercise

Download the full response
DownloadRelated resources

Science city, research region: how to build R&D into local identity
05 December 2024
Polling shows place-based awareness and alliances can be foundations for national support, says Kim Shillinglaw. This post first appeared in Research Fortnight on 21st November 2024.

Public Attitudes to R&D: Global-Facing R&D
04 December 2024
This briefing summarises attitudes to global-facing R&D, research conducted in the UK, but whose benefits are felt outside the UK.

People’s Vision for R&D: How to move from principles to action
09 September 2024
As part of CaSE’s People’s Vision for R&D public dialogue project exploring society’s stake in R&D, CaSE has made recommendations for action from the R&D sector.

Public Opinion during the 2024 General Election Campaign: universities and international talent
24 July 2024
CaSE’s latest public opinion poll, carried out during the election campaign in June 2024, explores the UK public’s feelings about international students and researchers coming to UK universities.